Arsenic - Amy Lyrics

I went on a date with a girl named Amy
I got there late, I didn't know the spot
She had me down for being crazy
For seeing Stars in freckled polkadots

Instead of seeing her I saw the one who shares her name
I know it's cruel. I'm sorry for what I put you through

She talks about the things that make her smile
A romantic dinner - it would have been her first one in a while
She reminds me of the girl I wish I knew
So it didn't matter that she was flattered by compliments for you

I can't have a future with imaginary dates
I know it's cruel. I'm sorry for what I did to you

The girl named Amy, with Stars inside her eyes
The girl named Amy, who took me by surprise