Your eyes, dark enough to hypnotize
Your hands, wrapped around mine felt so right
Sometimes, I will simply close my eyes
And you will wipe away the tears I couldn't hide, hide
But you had your pride
Why ya gotta be so darn stupid
Why ya gotta rely on Cupid to make me fall
Right back to you
Why ya gotta make up excuses
Why ya gotta make me feel useless
Piercing rain, but back like morning dew
Yeah, I didn't think that'd be you
You said, it's rare to find someone like you
But then, drifting off you found somebody new
When I stayed true
Why ya gotta be so darn stupid
Why ya gotta rely on Cupid to make me fall
Right back to you
Why ya gotta make up excuses
Why ya gotta make me feel useless
Piercing rain, but back like morning dew
Yeah, I didn't think that'd be you
Let's go back to the evergreen
It's just you and me, and our crazy dreams
Let's go back to the darkened sea
Living out of a fantasy
Let's go back to the evergreen
Go back to the evergreen
Now it's only me, and a worn-out scene
Why you gotta be so darn stupid
Why you still rely on Cupid to make me want to
Come back to you
Well that's just not how I do
Yeah, I didn't think that'd be you