You said youd call me at 5
but you lied so obviously
I'm not the one on your mind
but i won't cry
you have me so hypnotized
and it's crazy but every word you say
i believe but you acted different
so distant and quick to leave
i know if i stay it will just cause more pain
but i cant let you go
Chorus
Baby why do you have to be so amazing to me
I try just to walk away
but your blue eyes make me stay
Baby you make this so confusing
either way I'm losing
baby why do you have to be so amazing to me
you said you hate to talk on the phone
so baby when i got home
and we were finally alone
all wrapped up in your arms in bed
you swore youd be here til the end
but its different now
and i dont know how
things got this way you seem so far away
and i know if i stay
it will just cause more pain
but i cant let you go
Chorus
Baby why do you have to be so amazing to me
I try just to walk away
but your blue eyes make me stay
Baby you make this so confusing
either way I'm losing
baby why do you have to be so amazing to me
It's like I'm holding on to someone i don't even know anymore
everythings changed
and your not the same
please come through that, through that door
Chorus
Baby why do you have to be so amazing to me
I try just to walk away
but your blue eyes make me stay
baby why cant you love me now
and leave no doubt baby
why do you have to be so amazing